How To Select Your First Handgun (2025)

If you are new to handguns, this guide will help you understand what to look for and why it matters. The focus is on reliability, simplicity, and cost-effective ways to get quality gear without wasting money.

Disclaimer: This article is not legal advice. Always consult your local laws and regulations regarding what firearms are legal and available in your area.


Start with a 9mm Polymer Striker-Fired Handgun

What is Polymer?
Polymer means the frame of the gun is made from high-strength plastic instead of metal. This makes the gun lighter, corrosion-resistant, and generally more affordable. Today, polymer-framed pistols are the standard for both concealed carry and duty use.

What is Striker-Fired?
Striker-fired pistols use an internal spring-loaded firing pin instead of an external hammer. This makes the pistol:

  • Easier to learn (the trigger pull is consistent every time)

  • Safer to carry (drop safeties are built in)

  • Simpler to maintain (fewer moving parts to break)


Best First Handguns (Reliable and Concealable)

All of these are chambered in 9mm, striker-fired, polymer-framed, and widely available in optics-ready versions.

Glock Options

  • Glock 45 – The gold standard for reliability. Double Stack.  

  • Glock 19 -- Mid-size, 15 rounds, works well for most people.

  • Glock 43X MOS – Slimmer, easier to conceal, optics-ready, 10 rounds.

  • Glock 48 MOS – Similar to the 43X but slightly longer slide and barrel for better accuracy and recoil control. Perfect for people with smaller hands who still want a full grip.

  • Glock 26 – Subcompact “baby Glock” with a 10-round magazine. Accepts larger Glock mags if needed.

Sig Sauer Options

  • Sig P365 – Compact, optics-ready, excellent trigger feel. Popular for everyday carry.

  • Sig P365XL – Longer slide and grip than the P365, but still slim and concealable.

  • Sig P320 Compact – Available everywhere, but has a history of drop-fire issues so not the top recommendation.

Smith & Wesson Options

  • M&P Shield Plus – Slim, good capacity, budget-friendly.

  • M&P 2.0 Compact – Full grip feel, optics-ready, solid build.

  • M&P Shield EZ 9mm – Designed for shooters with smaller hands or reduced hand strength. Easy-to-rack slide and light recoil spring.

Springfield Armory Options

  • Hellcat Pro – 15-round slimline pistol with optics-ready slide. Competes directly with the Glock 48 MOS.

  • XD-S Mod.2 – Single-stack slim carry pistol. Good for shooters who prefer a narrow grip.

Walther Options

  • Walther PDP F-Series – Specifically designed for shooters with smaller hands. Reduced grip circumference, shortened trigger reach, and lighter slide racking force.

  • Walther PPS M2 – Slim, reliable single-stack option with excellent ergonomics.


Add a Compact Weapon Light

Being able to identify threats in low light is critical.

Recommended:

  • Streamlight TLR-7 Sub – Fits Glock 43X/48 MOS, Sig P365, and other subcompacts. 500 lumens, durable, and adds minimal bulk.

Why add a light?

  • Identify threats in the dark

  • Improve grip and control

  • Train realistically for real-world scenarios


Use a Quality Holster

The holster is as important as the firearm. A bad holster is unsafe.

Recommended:

  • Alien Gear Photon – Works with most optics and lights, adjustable cant and retention, comfortable for everyday carry.

  • Other solid choices: Tenicor, Tier 1 Concealed, PHLster


Consider an Optics-Ready Model

A red dot optic helps new shooters acquire their sight picture faster under stress. Look for models marked MOS (Glock), OR (Smith & Wesson), or ROMEOZero-ready (Sig).

Entry-level red dots:

  • Holosun 407k/507k

  • Shield RMSc

  • Trijicon RMRcc (higher end option)


How to Save Money

  • Police Trade-Ins – Glock 19s and M&Ps are often under $400.

  • GSSF Membership – Join Glock Shooting Sports Foundation. A $75 membership gets you a $150 discount coupon once a year on select Glocks.

  • Pawn Shops – In some states you can find good-condition used handguns below MSRP.

  • Buy Once, Cry Once – A handgun is a defensive tool meant to save your life. Take the time to save and buy from a reputable manufacturer.


State-Specific Considerations

California – 10-round magazine limit. Must choose from the California Handgun Roster. Common options are Glock 19 Gen 3 or M&P Shield CA-compliant models.

New York – Magazine limit is 10 rounds. Long permit process varies by county. Expect several months from application to approval.

New Jersey – 10-round mag limit. Mandatory permit-to-purchase and Firearms ID. Hollow points only allowed in home defense.

Massachusetts – Requires a License to Carry (LTC). Must choose from MA-compliant list. Glock models must be Gen 3 or earlier.

Illinois – FOID card required before purchase. Separate training and permit required for concealed carry.

Hawaii – 10-round mag limit, long waiting period, mandatory registration, limited approved models.

Connecticut – Permit required to buy and carry. 10-round mag limit. Training course and background check required.

Washington, D.C. – Very limited handgun options. All firearms must be registered. Carry permits are difficult to obtain.


If you live in Houston, please consider joining us for a Basics class or a Dry Fire Class. Tools are important but training is what makes the difference.



Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.